Archive

Archive for December, 2008

The Best Lego Stories of 2008 [Lego]

December 31st, 2008
Bricks! Minifigs! Spaceships! Star Wars! Airplanes! Robots! Sex! Secret Vaults! Our exclusive trip to the Lego mothership! More than six million readers viewed the best Lego stories of 2008 in...

Technology

Larger iPod Touch In Apple’s Future?

December 31st, 2008
Ender_Stonebender writes "TechCrunch is reporting that three independent sources have mentioned to them a large form factor version of the iPod Touch, with either a 7 or 9 inch screen, to be released fall of 2009. The device is expected to have access to the iTunes App Store. Beyond that, everything about it appears to be pure speculation."

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

Technology ,

Engadget’s top posts, 2008

December 31st, 2008

Well, the year has come and gone, and with it, our 365 -- or in this case, 366 -- days of posting. We've seen some pretty amazing stuff, gotten to play with a stack of awesome gear, and watched the site grow by leaps and bounds (we just had our biggest day ever in October). We thought we'd cap the year off with a look back at the posts that got the most heat. One thing that's clear? People really love (or hate) Apple. Check out the top 20 of the year below, and be sure to truck over to Engadget Mobile and Engadget HD for their year-end round-ups!

Top 20 most trafficked posts of 2008 (in order)

    1. Steve Jobs keynote live from WWDC 2008
    2. Live from Apple's "spotlight turns to notebooks" event
    3. Live from Apple's 'Let's Rock' event in San Francisco
    4. Live from Macworld 2008: Steve Jobs keynote
    5. Live from Apple's iPhone SDK press conference
    6. iPhone 3G is finally official, starts at $199, available July 11th
    7. The second-gen iPhone: 3G, GPS, only slightly thicker
    8. iPhone 3G review
    9. BlackBerry Storm review
    10. Meet the T-Mobile G1
    11. Sony Ericsson's XPERIA X1 QWERTY with Windows Mobile and HSUPA
    12. Woman files $54m lawsuit against Best Buy for losing laptop
    13. The HTC Touch Pro
    14. MacBook Air review
    15. Dell E and E Slim revealed, taking on Eee and Air in one fell swoop
    16. Worst parents in the world punk kid into thinking he got an Xbox 360
    17. T-Mobile G1 review
    18. T-Mobile G1 first hands-on (updated)
    19. iPhone firmware 2.0 hands-on
    20. The Simpsons mocks (m)Apple

Top 20 most trafficked posts during 2008 (in order; non-2008 posts in bold)

    1. Steve Jobs keynote live from WWDC 2008
    2. Live from Apple's "spotlight turns to notebooks" event
    3. Live from Apple's 'Let's Rock' event in San Francisco
    4. Live from Macworld 2008: Steve Jobs keynote
    5. Live from Apple's iPhone SDK press conference
    6. iPhone 3G is finally official, starts at $199, available July 11th
    7. The second-gen iPhone: 3G, GPS, only slightly thicker
    8. HOW-TO: Get music OFF your iPod
    9. iPhone 3G review
    10. BlackBerry Storm review
    11. Meet the T-Mobile G1
    12. Sony Ericsson's XPERIA X1 QWERTY with Windows Mobile and HSUPA
    13. Turn your PC into a Mac
    14. HOW-TO: Get videos and DVDs onto your Sony PlayStation Portable (PSP) for free
    15. Woman files $54m lawsuit against Best Buy for losing laptop
    16. The HTC Touch Pro
    17. iPhone unlocked: AT&T loses iPhone exclusivity, August 24, 2007, 12:00PM EDT
    18. MacBook Air review
    19. Dell E and E Slim revealed, taking on Eee and Air in one fell swoop
    20. Blu-ray vs HD DVD: State of the Division

Top 15 most trafficked posts of the year, sans Apple-only posts (in order)

    1. BlackBerry Storm review
    2. Meet the T-Mobile G1
    3. Sony Ericsson's XPERIA X1 QWERTY with Windows Mobile and HSUPA
    4. Woman files $54m lawsuit against Best Buy for losing laptop
    5. The HTC Touch Pro
    6. Dell E and E Slim revealed, taking on Eee and Air in one fell swoop
    7. Worst parents in the world punk kid into thinking he got an Xbox 360
    8. T-Mobile G1 review
    9. T-Mobile G1 first hands-on (updated)
    10. Little old lady suing Sony, Samsung, Nokia and everyone else for infringing on her laser patents
    11. Sony gets official with PSP-3000
    12. The PS3 Laptop: from Ben Heck to Engadget with love
    13. Holiday Gift Guide: $1001+
    14. Best Buy offers HD DVD owners $10 million in gift cards, trade in, shoulder to cry on
    15. HP's UMPC 2133 revealed

A few other interesting numbers for you:

Total posts on Engadget in 2008: 11,878
Total number of comments: 697,672 (and counting)
Average comments per post: 58.7

Combined Engadget classic, HD, and Mobile stats:

Posts: 21,880
Comments: 853,044
Average comments per post: 39.0

Filed under:

Engadget's top posts, 2008 originally appeared on Engadget on Wed, 31 Dec 2008 23:59:00 EST. Please see our terms for use of feeds.

Permalink | Email this | Comments

Technology

PRC orders Qwest to restore Internet service

December 31st, 2008

LAS CRUCES, N.M. (AP) — New Mexico regulators have ordered Qwest to restore service to independently owned and operated Internet service provider SkyWi Inc. after it disconnected the provider because of a $1.7 million debt.

The state Public Regulation Commission held an emergency meeting Wednesday and ordered Qwest to immediately begin the process of restoring service to critical SkyWi customers and to report back to the PRC by Friday morning.

Under the order, if Qwest is unable to restore service by Thursday morning, Qwest must show cause why it should not be sanctioned.

The PRC wants SkyWi to give Qwest a list of its customers prioritized by public health and safety and also by economic concerns by 9 a.m. Thursday. The commission also ordered SkyWi to release control of customers' telephone numbers to enable those customers to seek alternative providers.

Albuquerque-based SkyWi buys wholesale Internet services through Qwest before reselling them to its customers. Qwest had asked SkyWi to pay more than $580,000 by Monday to continue the service, said Qwest spokesman Mark Molzen.

Tuesday's disconnection was no surprise to SkyWi, Molzen said.

"We notified SkyWi several months in advance and numerous times," he said.

SkyWi's chief development officer, Don Levy, said it owes money to Qwest, but not $1.7 million. He would not disclose how much SkyWi believes it owes.

He also would not say whether SkyWi customers were notified service was being disconnected.

The decision to disconnect SkyWi affected Eddy County government, which found itself without phone service and scrambled to get hooked back up. The system was provided by One Connect.

Eddy County Manager Steve Massey in Carlsbad said he had not known in advance that Qwest was disconnecting SkyWi. The Eddy County sheriff's 911 emergency line was not affected.

SkyWi sued Qwest in December, alleging anti-competitive behavior.

"We have no issue with Qwest competing with us for the same customers, as that is the nature of healthy competition," Jack Leach, president of SkyWi, said in a news release. "But Qwest has opted to take unfair advantage of their control over the telecom networks in this region to create barriers that destroy the competitiveness of smaller ISPs."

SkyWi acquired One Connect IP and ZiaNet in September, and Levy said SkyWi realized there were problems between the two companies and Qwest.

The lawsuit accuses Qwest of willfully and routinely engaging in practices designed to remove effective competition from its markets, Levy said.

The PRC said it's decision to require Qwest to restore service to critical customers is an interim order pending a decision by the federal court on SkyWi's request for a preliminary injunction in its lawsuit against Qwest.

Technology

Viacom Threatens To Pull Content Offline … (Karl Bode/DSLreports)

December 31st, 2008

Karl Bode / DSLreports:
Viacom Threatens To Pull Content Offline - While Time Warner tells us customers will see refunds...  This morning we noted how a feud between Time Warner Cable and Viacom could result in Time Warner Cable and BrightHouse customers losing Nickelodeon, MTV, Comedy Central and 16 other channels.

Technology

Viacom to Time Warner: We’ll take Dora, and online episodes too

December 31st, 2008

Time Warner Cable and Viacom’s drawn-out feud over rights fees could result in 13 million Time Warner and Bright House customers losing 19 popular channels, including Comedy Central, MTV and Nickelodeon, on January 1. That’s right, you could be saying sayonara to The Daily Show, The Hills and Spongebob Squarepants as soon as the clock strikes midnight. But that’s not all: Viacom is also threatening to yank online content. Happy New Year, eh?

Viacom’s cable networks are distributed by Time Warner, the fourth largest cable television provider in the U.S. Viacom has posted a message on sites it owns, such as MTV.com and VH1.com, alerting customers that they will lose their favorite shows on TV and online unless they act fast. Time Warner Cable’s director of digital communication (or someone posing as him), posted the following screencap to Twitter, according to DSL Reports, while Time Warner in-house speculation is brewing over whether or not the message is a scare tactic or if Viacom is ballsy enough to follow through with its threats.

“They’re somehow going to block Time Warner Cable / Bright House/ Roadrunner subscribers only from seeing their free video content, probably by blocking a range of IP addresses,” Time Warner theorizes on the site Long Reply (useful when Twitter’s 140 character limit just isn’t enough). That sounds a bit far-fetched and complicated to pull off, if not impossible.

Time Warner doesn’t see why it has to pay Viacom more for content that’s available so readily online, especially since that arguably diminishes the content’s value. Why would customers pay more for cable (an additional $3 a month) during a recession if anyone can watch the shows for free from multiple sources? Those sources include the show’s own website, Hulu and Comcast’s Fancast, as Media Memo points out. However, cable subscription revenues will still trump any money brought in from online advertising. We’ll be hearing the phrase “analog dollars versus digital pennies” for awhile yet, unfortunately.

Viacom’s multi-pronged approach to convincing customers to riot also includes running TV ads asking its viewers to call Time Warner Cable and complain. Unsurprisingly, the ads have already made it to YouTube. Did someone say phone tree?

Finally, I leave you with some emergency rations in case the lovers’ quarrel isn’t settled in time, an outcome that could cost Time Warner Cable valuable customers and Viacom precious advertising revenue. It isn’t quite Nickelodeon favorite Dora the Explorer, but if Viacom’s really taking her off the air and offline, at least you’ll have Maraka and Mittens to comfort you.

Technology

Viacom to Time Warner: We???ll take Dora, and online episodes too

December 31st, 2008

Time Warner Cable and Viacom’s drawn-out feud over rights fees could result in 13 million Time Warner and Bright House customers losing 19 popular channels, including Comedy Central, MTV and Nickelodeon, on January 1. That’s right, you could be saying sayonara to The Daily Show, The Hills and Spongebob Squarepants as soon as the clock strikes midnight. But that’s not all: Viacom is also threatening to yank online content. Happy New Year, eh?

Viacom’s cable networks are distributed by Time Warner, the fourth largest cable television provider in the U.S. Viacom has posted a message on sites it owns, such as MTV.com and VH1.com, alerting customers that they will lose their favorite shows on TV and online unless they act fast. Time Warner Cable’s director of digital communication (or someone posing as him), posted the following screencap to Twitter, according to DSL Reports, while Time Warner in-house speculation is brewing over whether or not the message is a scare tactic or if Viacom is ballsy enough to follow through with its threats.

“They’re somehow going to block Time Warner Cable / Bright House/ Roadrunner subscribers only from seeing their free video content, probably by blocking a range of IP addresses,” Time Warner theorizes on the site Long Reply (useful when Twitter’s 140 character limit just isn’t enough). That sounds a bit far-fetched and complicated to pull off, if not impossible.

Time Warner doesn’t see why it has to pay Viacom more for content that’s available so readily online, especially since that arguably diminishes the content’s value. Why would customers pay more for cable (an additional $3 a month) during a recession if anyone can watch the shows for free from multiple sources? Those sources include the show’s own website, Hulu and Comcast’s Fancast, as Media Memo points out. However, cable subscription revenues will still trump any money brought in from online advertising. We’ll be hearing the phrase “analog dollars versus digital pennies” for awhile yet, unfortunately.

Viacom’s multi-pronged approach to convincing customers to riot also includes running TV ads asking its viewers to call Time Warner Cable and complain. Unsurprisingly, the ads have already made it to YouTube. Did someone say phone tree?

Finally, I leave you with some emergency rations in case the lovers’ quarrel isn’t settled in time, an outcome that could cost Time Warner Cable valuable customers and Viacom precious advertising revenue. It isn’t quite Nickelodeon favorite Dora the Explorer, but if Viacom’s really taking her off the air and offline, at least you’ll have Maraka and Mittens to comfort you.

Technology

On Staying Happy

December 31st, 2008
A few weeks ago, we got an email sent to the feedback box that asked how we can possibly stay upbeat. I have to apologize because I can't find the email anymore -- so I don't remember who sent it -- but he pointed out that while he really enjoyed reading Techdirt and liked what we had to say, the stories about corporate cluelessness, political corruption and short-sighted thinking were so consistently frustrating and depressing that there were times he considered giving up on reading Techdirt -- if just to keep himself from banging his head against the wall. He wanted to know how we possibly stayed upbeat, and kept positive enough to avoid giving ourselves heart attacks. I didn't get a chance to email him back, but wanted to address the question here as my final post of 2008.

Techdirt has been going strong since 1997, so it's not like we're new to covering these sorts of things. But, in the end, I personally stay extremely happy and optimistic because I see how far we've come -- and I recognize the inevitable outcome of most of these debates. Yes, we point out plenty of bad stuff, but it's not about complaining about how terrible things are -- but about trying to help open some eyes to the possibilities of moving forward, adapting and embracing new technological possibilities. And, while there are some extremely loud and public holdouts, every day we're seeing examples of it working. We see the inevitable results of technological change in enabling new and powerful business models that greatly expand markets, provide consumers with much more than before, and enable new innovations that you might never have thought were possible before.

The internet is a phenomenal communications tool that very few people had even heard of not so long ago. The world wide web only came into being slightly more than fifteen years ago. The ability to go online and find just about anything you need in seconds is a brand new phenomenon. The fact that you can talk to people, easily, in far away places -- make new connections, share stories, exchange ideas, debate, argue and connect, well beyond your local community -- is all simply amazing. Beyond online communications, the internet has provided new and amazing tools for business, commerce, entertainment and information that were nearly impossible to imagine by all but the most visionary people just a few decades ago.

How can you not be optimistic and excited when you look back at how far we've come in such a short time, and think about how much further we can go?

Yes, we're in the midst of a brutal financial mess -- but that won't stop innovation. Yes, incumbent forces, with short-sighted plans and a desire to hold back the tides are annoying and disruptive (not in a good way) in the short run. But even they are finding they can't hold back progress. Robert Friedel has a wonderful book called A Culture of Improvement that details how we, as a society, are constantly looking to improve on what we already have. We add ideas and ingenuity to old concepts and build something better -- not because of the desire to grab some "intellectual property," but because of the desire to improve our own lot, to build a better tool that we want to use. Incumbent short-sighted players have been able to hinder and harm progress, but they can't keep it down completely. That culture of improvement can't be stopped entirely.

There is, of course, plenty to be vigilant about, of course. Bad and corrupt political moves can seriously stunt economic improvement, but history has shown that such periods are often short-lived, as the need for continued economic growth and advancement is impossible to stomp out completely -- and as it seeps out through the cracks, legacy businesses crumble, and outdated political rules and short-sighted policies are pushed to the side. Yes, more come along, often as the innovators of yesterday seek to stop the innovators of tomorrow, but the march of innovation hasn't been stopped yet.

So, yes, we rant and rage against short-sighted policies, and efforts that hinder and delay the inevitable, but we're excited and optimistic and happy about what we see as the eventual possibilities from that advancement and innovation. Any "anger" or "unhappiness" we might display is more frustration at ourselves for not being able to clearly paint a picture -- for those seeking to hold back progress -- of just what opportunities moving forward provides.

As we move into 2009, there are plenty of things to be worried about, but look around at what progress has brought to us already, and look at the trends and the obvious direction in which technology is taking us -- there's so much to look forward to, it's hard to let any depression seep into the discussion at all.
Happy New Year to all of the many readers of Techdirt, whether you agree with us or disagree with us, and we look forward to seeing what great new things come about in the new year and beyond.


Permalink | Comments | Email This Story


Technology

Official response for Zune 30 Freezing Issue (Zune 30gb stuck at reboot screen) (Matt Akers/forums.zune.net)

December 31st, 2008

Matt Akers / forums.zune.net:
Official response for Zune 30 Freezing Issue (Zune 30gb stuck at reboot screen)  —  Early this morning we were alerted by our customers that there was a widespread issue affecting our 2006 model Zune 30GB devices (a large number of which are still actively being used).

Technology

Reports: 30GB Zunes Failing Everywhere, All At Once (John Herrman/Gizmodo)

December 31st, 2008

John Herrman / Gizmodo:
Reports: 30GB Zunes Failing Everywhere, All At Once  —  Right, so this is a weird one: we're getting tons of reports—tons—about failing Zune 30s.  Apparently, the players began freezing at about midnight last night, becoming totally unresponsive and practically useless.

Technology

The iPhone dominated our Apple headlines this year

December 31st, 2008

There’s simply no denying that 2008 was a good year for Apple. Sales of just about everything were up, and market share of went up, but the real gems for the company were the iPhone 3G its accompanying App Store. Our top stories about Apple this year, definitely reflect that — as yes, all of the top ones were about the iPhone or the App Store

This list is mostly based on popularity, but in some cases there were multiple stories on a topic, so we included others in the list.

Counting down:

10) The iPhone outsells that thing I’m using as a paperweight (the RAZR)

At one time, Motorola’s RAZR was the most popular phone in the United States by far. But times have changed, and that device (which yes, I still have but don’t use) looks laughably old compared to devices like any BlackBerry, the G1 and yes, the iPhone. That last device was the first one to displace the RAZR as the top selling mobile phone for U.S. consumers after 12 consecutive quarters of RAZR dominance.

9) About those “rampant” iPhone 2.2 problems

CNET’s iPhone Atlas blog ran a report that made it sound as if the iPhone 2.2 software was a complete disaster — the problem was that no one seemed to agree with them. Of their 17 comments at the time, 15 reported no problems whatsoever. Dozens more did in our comments and on sites this story appears on like Digg. This was pure hyperbole.

8) So much for my time away from the computer — Google Reader for the iPhone improves

I’m addicted to Google Reader, so when Google launched a version that was designed specifically for the iPhone, I was in heaven. This was before the iPhone 3G, so it was all browser-based, but it worked so well that it still actually is browser-based, and I still use it daily.

7) MG’s 10 favorite iPhone apps of 2008

The App Store, in my opinion, was the best thing Apple did in 2008. After the launch of the first iPhone in 2007, Apple tried to make third-party developers create apps that would only work in the device’s Safari web browser, but only a handful made really good one. When Apple opened up its main screen to native third party apps however, development exploded.

6) The real iPhone 3G rip-off: Text messages

While so many people were worried about the “true” cost of the iPhone after Apple announced the price of the iPhone 3G would only be $199, I was surprised that more people weren’t outraged about the real rip-off being pulled by AT&T, it’s text message add-on plan. Previously, with the original iPhone you at least got 200 text messages for free along with your “unlimited” data plan, but they killed those free messages with the iPhone 3G. Now those same 200 message costs you an extra $5 a month — which is a joke. It’s such a small amount of data, and it costs the carriers basically no more to send a lot versus a little.

5) iPhone 3G: You can buy one without a contract, but not on launch day

This story is interesting, because AT&T did indicate just prior to the iPhone 3G launch that it would eventually make the device available to purchase without signing a contract. But six months after the launch, that still hasn’t happened. At the time, the company said it would be $599 for the 8GB version and $699 for the 16GB version with no contract, but by the time AT&T allows for the no-contract purchases (if they ever do), we may well only have 16GB and 32GB versions of the phone. Other countries are selling the device without contracts already, hurry up America.

4) What’s in the iPhone 2.2 software update and beyond

The iPhone software 2.0, which launched with the iPhone 3G hardware, was very buggy to start with. While the 2.1 update fixed many of the issues, the 2.2 update really solidified the experience. It also brought a bunch of new cool features like Google Street View. But the next updates will hopefully include more things that people want — like copy and paste for the love of God!

3) MG’s 10 favorite iPhone games of 2008

Games on the iPhone were huge — it’s the largest category in the App Store. While not everyone was convinced early on that the iPhone could be a legitimate gaming platform, big time developers like EA making making games like SimCity and Namco making I Love Katamari for the iPhone proved it’s a new gaming force — and that you could actually sell games for more than $0.99. The best game though has to be Ngmoco’s Rolando [iTunes Link], which was developed just for the iPhone.

2) Beware, Nintendo DS: video games come of age on the iPhone 3G

Let me repeat myself: Games on the iPhone were huge this year. Even VentureBeat’s own Dean Takahashi, who was skeptical of gaming on the device early on, got on board after trying out some of the games. As he wrote, “But Apple realizes that the iPhone 3G is an outstanding game platform, thanks to the multi-touch display, great sound, good graphics, and the accelerometer-based tilt feature. Nintendo’s DS handheld doesn’t have tilt or multi-touch, and its graphics and sound aren’t outstanding.”

1) iPhone fart app pulls in nearly $10,000 a day

While some might find it inappropriate (pun intended) that this was one of our top Apple stories, I find it very appropriate. It shows not only is the App Store a huge success for all types of developers, but that Apple made the right call in making the app approval process less strict. These fart apps may be crass and silly, but as the saying goes, “the customer is always right.” And sales of this particular farting app, iFart Mobile, actually exploded even further in the days that followed.

Technology

A Robotic Cyberknife To Fight Cancer

December 31st, 2008
Roland Piquepaille writes "The Cyberknife is not a real knife. This is a robot radiotherapy machine which works with great accuracy during treatment, thanks to its robotic arm which moves around a patient when he breathes. According to BBC News, the first Cyberknife will be operational in February 2009 in London, UK. But other machines have been installed in more than 15 countries, and have permitted to treat 50,000 patients in the first semester of 2008. And the Cyberknife is more efficient than conventional radiotherapy devices. The current systems require twenty or more short sessions with low-dose radiation. On the contrary, and because it's extremely precise, a Cyberknife can deliver powerful radiation in just three sessions."

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

Technology ,

Dev-Team teases v2.2-compatible iPhone 3G unlock for the New Year

December 31st, 2008

Ever since the Dev-Team kinda sorta promised that they would have a neatly packaged iPhone 3G unlock ready for release by the year's end, we've all been waiting on pins and needles, counting down the moments until freedom was in hand yet again. Now, a cryptic message on the crew's blog has been followed up with a not-at-all secretive image (shown above), which shows that whatever magic they've got going on will work with the latest (v2.2) iPhone 3G firmware. According to a related writeup at yellowsn0w, we're clearly told that the unlock tool will be made available by midnight PST at the latest, though we're hoping those guys have their AM / PM mixed up -- otherwise, you might be waiting until noontime tomorrow. At any rate, now you've more than a day off and black eyed peas to look forward to tomorrow, right?

Via yellowsn0w and MobileCrunch]

Filed under:

Dev-Team teases v2.2-compatible iPhone 3G unlock for the New Year originally appeared on Engadget on Wed, 31 Dec 2008 21:44:00 EST. Please see our terms for use of feeds.

Read | Permalink | Email this | Comments

Technology

Where’s That Line Between True Democracy And Mob Rule?

December 31st, 2008
Way back in 7th grade social studies class, I still remember one of the first assignments we had from Mr. Kemp (I think that was his name...) was to make a suggestion for a way to change or improve the way government functions. My suggestion was that in addition to the two legislative branches (the House of Representatives and the Senate), we could add a third branch for direct citizen voting on bills. I think I called it the Peoplocracy or something. Whenever it was time to vote on various bills, the information would be broadcast via TV, and individuals could call a phone number and "vote" one way or the other. I remember that I got a bad grade on the paper, as the teacher told me such an idea made no sense: our elected officials in Congress where there to represent the will of the people, and direct voting on bills by citizens was entirely redundant and unnecessary. To this day, I still feel the teacher dismissed the idea too quickly... but that doesn't mean it's necessarily a good idea.

Since the election there have been a bunch of stories about how President-elect Obama has built up this huge direct line of communication to a huge, passionate and committed group of citizens and supporters via the internet, and there's plenty of speculation about how he intends to use that connection to help push his legislative agenda forward. In many ways, this is quite exciting, and I'm curious to see how it works -- and hoping for the best. After all, a huge problem with our elected officials in the past is that they were so far disconnected from the citizens they were supposed to represent that their policy choices were often backwards. Instead, it was often the powerful lobbyists who got through and were able to fashion laws to support their positions, rather than the overall well-being of the citizenry.

Anything that gives the actual people a bigger voice and a better ability to communicate and connect with the President or other elected officials seems like a great idea -- and we're already seeing some of that in action with the Obama's impressive Change.gov operation, which, among other things allows people to submit policy ideas and allows others to vote on them, in a Digg-like fashion. The possibilities for such a program are potentially limitless and incredibly powerful.

And yet... I'm still left wondering if there isn't a huge risk as well. As we've seen time and time again, powerful technologies don't discriminate. They can be used for very good purposes and they can be used for very bad purposes as well. I'm very excited about the good possibilities, but I'm wondering how much thought is being given to limiting the downside possibilities. There is, of course, the risk of "mob rule"-type decision making at times. While majority rules is the foundation of democracy, there are times when a simple majority can end up taking away the rights of a minority or put in place a dreadful and dangerous policy. This can happen especially after emotionally-charged incidents, where "mob rule" and thoughts of revenge or punishment overrule the rational parts of many people. Also, with any such system, there is the risk of gaming. As we've unfortunately seen with Digg over the past year or so, a small group of individuals have figured out how to effectively control the system, almost entirely stomping out the voices of others.

I don't think this is where things are headed, and I'm not saying that the technology or embracing a direct connection to people is a bad thing. I think just the opposite is true. I'm really excited to see where all of this leads, and the fact that there's at least some indication that we're not dealing with politics as usual is great. But... in seeing everyone talk up how wonderful this is, I worry about what's being done to at least guard against the worst abuses that occur when a direct connection to the people turns from rational into irrational mob rule out for blood.

Permalink | Comments | Email This Story


Technology

Evite fails on the year???s biggest party night

December 31st, 2008

Update: It’s past 9pm Pacific time, meaning that it’s now New Year’s Day on the East Coast … and Evite is still down. I think it’s safe to say that this isn’t planned maintenance, or if it is, it went horribly awry.

No one cool uses Evite anymore. You know this. I know this. Auren Hoffman, chief executive of search startup RapLeaf and an investor in competitor Socializr, wrote a column for us two years ago about why he hates Evite. But it’s still the biggest event website around.

Well, we can add another item to Hoffman’s litany of complaints — Evite is down on New Year’s Eve. That’s right, it’s down on the biggest party night of the year, meaning the event details stored on the site are now inaccessible to partygoers. And according to the site, the down time — which only includes “certain pages” (like, um, the main Evite site) — is due to scheduled maintenance. Now, I’m not really sure what’s going on; I’m guessing that Evite is having trouble dealing with traffic, and the “planned maintenance” message is just the default error page.

But maybe we should take Evite at its word, and assume it really did schedule down time. For 6pm Pacific time on New Year’s Eve. Friends, that was a bad idea.

Meanwhile, if you sent out an Evite invitation to a New Year’s party — say, an invitation to the author of this post — I’d suggest resending it via email. Or maybe it’s time to give in and use Facebook Events.

Technology

Get Adobe Flash playerPlugin by wpburn.com wordpress themes